Grace Grandstrand

The implementation of the new paper Starbucks cups has been controversial among students

Starbucks around Minnesota has implemented several policies, some tests, and others permanent. They are encouraged to write nice messages on their cups, have a new refillable, reusable cup policy in-store, and most controversially, change from plastic to paper cups in some Starbucks around the state. These policies have pros and cons, with some students liking or disliking them.

The paper cup implementation, while not popular among students, has been for the good of the environment. Replacing the plastic cups with compostable paper cups is a more sustainable choice. Unlike the last ones, these cups naturally break down over time. “[Starbucks] wanted to care for the environment, but I’d rather have plastic,” said sophomore Isabella Rolfson.

Students are unhappy about the new cup material. The paper material gives the cup an odd texture, and the paper in its lid makes it soggy and less appetizing. Drinking from a paper cup is uncomfortable and makes the drink taste more like paper than the drink itself. “It’s like you’re sipping paper; it makes me uncomfortable,” said sophomore Maeve Steichen.

Students not only dislike the feeling and taste of the paper but also the look of the cup. Not being able to see the drink takes out a fundamental part of drinking it. For example, seeing the bright pink of a strawberry acai just makes the drink feel and taste better, and the white cups [don’t] allow you to see that color. “[The new cups] change the overall feel of the drink, the excitement, the excitement of seeing the color of your strawberry acai,” said senior Raquel Lynch.

While the new cups were not well-liked among the students, their other policies had more positive feedback. Sophomore Claire Dooley enjoys the new reusable cups and how you can get refills of the cup. She explains that it is not only eco-friendly but a good deal for the buyer, who no longer has to pay for their refills. The writing on the cup policy also helps spread kindness and positivity among customers, giving them motivational messages that can make their day. “I think [writing messages on the cups] is positive, and it makes me happy that other people are happy,” said Dooley.