The student news site of Benilde-St. Margaret's School in St. Louis Park, MN

The Decline

January 14, 2023

Thirty years ago, one hundred BSM students auditioned for roles in musicals and full risers of choir students sang at mass. But the cast list of White Christmas, BSM’s most recent production, included just 27 students. In the past two decades, many of BSM’s arts programs–band, choir, theater –have experienced a significant decline in participation. 

This decline is not the result of a single factor. Instead, a “perfect storm” of schedule changes, program competitors, administration’s decisions, and pandemic precautions limited students’ exposure to the arts. “It is not one thing, one teacher; it has been a constant almost hurricane over us since about 2006,” former Choir Director Nancy Stockhaus said. 

Beginning in the early 2000s, high schools specifically focused on the arts opened in the Minneapolis area. Schools like PIM (Performance Institute of Minnesota) and the Saint Paul Conservatory for Performing Artists make the arts a central part of curriculum and cater to students looking to pursue them professionally. Bigger public schools, like Wayzata or Minnetonka, have top-ranked arts programs that draw hundreds of students. As these programs develop, prospective BSM students who are serious about the arts often opt for those schools. 

“We noticed a big change in how many kids who were coming to Benilde who were interested in the arts because they had other options…we also had a lot of competition at that time from Minnetonka, Wayzata; they have superb theater programs because they’re huge schools. They drew from huge amounts of kids and we draw from maybe 1200 kids,” Stockhaus said. 

Even the students BSM does draw from usually favor sports over the arts. “I would say the large portion of our kids are involved in sports, especially now…I’ve noticed a big difference,” Stockhaus said. 

The emphasis was on science and everything associated with STEM. We pleaded with them to make it STEAM or STREAM, we could have done that. But STEM was the big thing. That put a crushing blow for us as well,

— Nancy Stockhaus

While simultaneously competing with these top schools, BSM’s arts program fell victim to a series of schedule changes. In the past decade, BSM has changed their schedule requirements almost every year. One of the more recent changes was the elimination of wellness during BSM hour. Students who couldn’t fit an elective in their schedule used their wellness to take choir. 

“For a musician that is terrible …It would be like telling the football or hockey team that your schedule has been shortened to 6 weeks. You will still get the same amount of time on the field/ice  but now 4/5 hour practices a day and 2 or 4 games a week. Then you are off for 9 months and are expected to be better when you show up next year with no further involvement/encouragement or guidance.  There is no logic to this scenario,” former Band Director Paul Keefe said in an email interview.

BSM alum (‘18) and recent Harvard grad Eric Wilson was a student who took advantage of the wellness hour to take arts classes. “I was in band and choir. I was in band as my “normal arts” and I would schedule my free hour for when the choir was practicing,” Wilson said. 

Even before the wellness requirement shifted, the BSM administration often encouraged students to pursue other electives. Engineering and biomed, two of BSM’s most popular electives, are often highlighted on social media and in tours for prospective students. This can be attributed to America’s greater focus on STEM in education. Beginning in the early 2010s, politicians, educators, and even corporations encouraged American schools to focus on STEM to push innovation and create a talented workforce. This focus on STEM can come at the expense of a well-rounded education, especially the arts.

“The emphasis was on science and everything associated with STEM. We pleaded with them to make it STEAM or STREAM, we could have done that. But STEM was the big thing. That put a crushing blow for us as well,” Stockhaus said. 

As BSM pushed harder for STEM, some students stopped taking choir because they felt the program didn’t get enough recognition.

“We only have two concerts throughout the year where we showcase everything we’ve learned. A lot of time feels wasted on rehearsing the same couple of songs over and over when we could be doing work,” senior and former choir member Greta Hall said. 

STEM became an educational buzzword around the same time that selectivity in college admissions skyrocketed. There is a common misconception that colleges prefer electives like engineering to arts classes like choir or band. Students aiming to attend a top college may opt for STEM electives instead of taking the arts. In reality, many colleges favor arts electives.

“Students believe erroneously that it’s all about academics. The richer candidate is not just academic…One extra AP class is not going to make the students stronger,” Carnegie Mellon University Dean of Admissions Mike Steidel said in the program of a public school’s band concert.  

As the above factors continued to hurt numbers, the pandemic delivered a crushing blow. The CDC’s social distancing and masking requirements made singing virtually impossible. Students playing outdoor sports could continue their seasons as normal, but the BSM choir and band programs had to get creative. Despite their creativity, it was difficult for the arts to recruit new students when they couldn’t actually sing. 

“The pandemic was a horrible time for the arts. We couldn’t be onstage, whereas kids in sports could be outside. We were tied to doing things on Zoom, and we know how terrible that is. Especially for singing,” Stockhaus said. 

Most recently, BSM cut the full-year arts requirements in the Junior High. Not only does this limit the numbers in the Junior High choir and band, it also limits exposure to programs students might be interested in in high school. 

“With everything else, that really slammed the band and choir. We didn’t have the opportunity to reach out to these kids and have them see the benefits of having a band or choir for a full year,” Stockhaus said. 

Like any athlete, musicians need to practice to perfect their craft. Limiting the Junior High requirement to only a half year prevents these students from reaching their full potential.

“If you’re going to do especially band and play an instrument, you need to do it for a full year. Otherwise you lose so much of your technique… it’s the same for singing. It’s a muscle. If you really want to be a singer, you don’t just do it for half a year,” Stockhaus said.

Leave a Comment

Knight Errant • Copyright 2024 • FLEX WordPress Theme by SNOLog in

Comments (0)

The Knight Errant intends for this area to be used to foster healthy, thought-provoking discussion. Comments are expected to adhere to our standards and to be respectful and constructive. As such, we do not permit the use of profanity, foul language, personal attacks, or the use of language that might be interpreted as libelous. Comments are reviewed and must be approved by a moderator to ensure that they meet these standards. The Knight Errant does not allow anonymous comments, and the Knight Errant requires first and last names and a valid email address in order for comments to be published. The email address will not be displayed but will be used to confirm your comments.
All Knight Errant Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *